Episode 71 Toby Anderson16 Year old Toby Eugene Anderson vanished from the Selma, Oregon area in the Fall of 1988.Toby was living with his Uncle, Almer "Billy" Wright, and Billy's children. One day without warning, Billy informed Toby's school that he had moved back to California to live with his father and would not be back.This proved not to be true, and Toby was never seen again. Following Toby's disappearance, his Uncle Billy gave conflicting stories as to what had happened with Toby, and where he might be. When it came to light that Billy had molested children, he was sentenced to a lengthy prison sentence. Toby's father looked for him for years and passed away without ever finding our what happened to his son. Years later, Toby's cousin Denise started looking into his disappearance, and came to suspect that he may have met with foul play at the hands of his Uncle Blly, and thinks he may have other victims out there. Since then, Denise has worked to find Toby but has faced roadblocks along the way, including being unable to search property where she thinks Toby's remains may be. She discusses her cousin Toby's case in this episode, and her efforts to see justice done.At the time he vanished, Toby Eugene Anderson was approximately 5ft5-5ft7, and weighed around 170 pounds, He had Brown hair and Green eyes. If you have information about Toby's case, please call the Oregon State Police at 800-442-2068Toby's case has been entered into NAMUS. There is an active Facebook group discussing Toby's case.If you'd like to support this podcast via a donation, you can do so through Patreon here-https://www.patreon.com/MissingPodcastTo contact the podcast or learn more about the cases we discuss visit:Missingpersonspodcast.comFollow us on Social media-Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/Missing-Persons-Podcast-103501877912153orTwitter:https://twitter.com/Missing_Pod

Episode 70 Marie Mueller43 year old mother of two, Marie Beula Mueller vanished in Frontenac, Missouri in March, 1972 during a messy separation and divorce from her husband, Dr. Donn W. Mueller, D.ODr. Mueller claimed that after returning home one day, he found his young chidlren home alone, and his estranged wife was missing although her car was still in the driveway. Dr. Mueller did not report Marie missing immediately and when he finally did, he claimed that she had taken a large sum of cash and jewelry with her. In the aftermath of Marie's disappearance, Dr. Mueller told his kids that their mom abandoned them, and went on with life as usual. But a string of witnesses came forward to tell police troubling details about Dr. Mueller in the time leading up to his wife going missing; details that included fraud, and discussion of how to murder his wife and dispose of her body to cover up the crime. Depite the belief by most people that Marie Mueller died at the hands of her husband, or that he played some kind of role in her disappearance, he was never charged in connection with Marie's case, and he went to his grave taking any secrets he had with him. Decades later as adults, Marie's children wanted to learn more about what happened to their mom, and were stunned when a police file detailing the case against their father came to light. In this episode, Marie's daughter Donna discusses her mom's case, and the troubling details of her father's possible involvement in her disappearance. At the time she vanished, Marie Beula Mueller was described as standing 5'4" - 5'6" and weighing 100-110 pounds. She had Red hair, blue eyes.and may have went by the nickname 'Sam'. Her maiden name is Smith. She had curved, claw-like fingernails, mastectomy scars on her chest, and two scars on her abdomen, one of which is from an appendectomy.If you have information about Marie Mueller, or her husband Dr. Donn Mueller, please contact the Frontenac Police Department at 314-373-6535If you'd like to support this podcast via a donation, you can do so through Patreon here-https://www.patreon.com/MissingPodcastTo contact the podcast or learn more about the cases we discuss visit:Missingpersonspodcast.comFollow us on Social media-Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/Missing-Persons-Podcast-103501877912153orTwitter:https://twitter.com/Missing_Pod

Episode 69 Judith Anne BrownIn 1977, 19 year-old Judith Anne Brown, who went by Judy was trying to improve her mental health situation. college student, and lifelong New York resident, Judy stayed behind when most of her family moved out of state to Kansas. It was after her family moved away, that Judy, who had suffered with OCD and depression, began to struggle with her mental health. Wanting to get help, she voluntarily checked herself into Creedmoor Hospital hoping to improve her situation. It was there that Judy crossed paths with another patient named Richard Riesenberg and began dating him. He was committed for the brutal 1971 murders of his wife and young son. Despite the murders he committed, he was able to come and go from the facility. Judy was transferred to another hospital and eventually discharged. In April,1977, Richard Riesenberg found out he was going to be transferred to another facility where he would no longer be free to come and go. Before that could happen, he walked away from Creedmoor hospital, and vanished. It was soon discovered that Judy was missing too. Although Judy spoke to family shortly after she went missing, she was never seen again. The focus by authorities seemed to be on taking Richard back into custody. Despite the fact that Judy was very likely with him, her name wasn't mentioned in news articles about his escape. Years after they vanished, Richard Riesenberg was reported to have called his attorney to talk about turning himself into the authorities, but he never did, and was never heard from again. At the time of that phone call, he claimed he was in California, but did not mention Judy. If she's alive, Judy would now be in her mid 60s. When she was last seen, Judy was described as bing 5ft2-5ft4, with Green eyes, and Sandy colored hair. Richard Riesenberg would be in his 80s if alive today, and at the time he went missing, had dark hair and wore glasses.If you have information about the whereabouts of Judith Anne Brown, or Richard Riesenberg, please call the NYC Missing Persons squad at (212) 694-7781.Check out the Facebook page about Judy's case. If you'd like to support this podcast via a donation, you can do so through Patreon here-https://www.patreon.com/MissingPodcastTo contact the podcast or learn more about the cases we discuss visit:Missingpersonspodcast.comFollow us on Social media-Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/Missing-Persons-Podcast-103501877912153orTwitter:https://twitter.com/Missing_Pod

Episode 68 Patricia Otto1976 was a trying time for 24 Year-Old wife & mother of 2, Patricia Lee Otto, or Patty as she went by. She had endured a very rocky relationship with her husband Ralph and the couple had broken up with plans of divorcing. Patty was working on a future without Ralph in he life and trying to provide a stable enviornment for her daughters. She was going to school, and during her split from Ralph, Patty even started dating a friend from her past. Somehow though, Patty reconciled with Ralph and decided to give the relationship another try. In early September, 1976, Ralph found out that Patty had dated someone during their time apart and was furious. In an angry, drunken range, he searched out the man Patty had dated intending to confront him gun in hand. He didn't find him and returned home where he confronted Patty leading to a violent argument. The couple's young daughters recalled seeing the argument get physical and before they knew it, Patty was missing.The next day, Ralph told his children that their mother had left them and didn't want to be a mom any longer.When Patty's family realized that Patty was missing, and that she hadn't taken her car or any of her belongings, they became worried and called police. Ralph told police various stories about where Patty had gone. Initially police thought that Patty had left to clear her head and would return soon. When days of her being missing turned into weeks, police became suspicious of Ralph but they had no evidence to prove Ralph had harmed Patty. Patty's case would go cold. The bodies of 2 women would eventually be found years after Patty vanished that police thought may have been Patty's. One was able to be ruled out, but the second body which was more promising, wound up being cremated. Today, more than 46 years after Patty was last seen, her case remains unsolved, and her family is still searching for her. If Patty's husband Ralph had any answers, he took them to the grave dying in prison for an unrelated crime. Patty's daughter Suzanne, who still recalls the last time she saw her mom in a heated argument with her father, discusses the case in this episode and her efforts to find out what happened to Patty. To learn more about Patty's case or share information, visit the Facebook Page Patty's Voice setup by Suzanne. Patty was described as 5'3, 140 pounds and was last seen wearing A white top and red slacks. If you have information about the disappearance of Patricia Otto, please call the Lewiston Police Department 208-746-0171If you'd like to support this podcast via a donation, you can do so through Patreon here-https://www.patreon.com/MissingPodcastTo contact the podcast or learn more about the cases we discuss visit:Missingpersonspodcast.comFollow us on Social media-Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/Missing-Persons-Podcast-103501877912153orTwitter:https://twitter.com/Missing_Pod

Episode 67 Matthew YeomansTwenty-five-year-old Matthew 'Matt' Yeomans went missing from his grandfather's Easton, Massachusetts home in the overnight hours of September 19, 2021 and hasn't been seen since.Matt's grandfather last saw Matt at around 9PM and when he woke up in the morning, Matt was gone. Matt's car was in the driveway, and his wallet, phone, and other belongings were still inside the home. The only thing missing seemed to be Matt himeself. Matt has Asperger's Syndrome, and usually was a homebody. Police questioned the few people that Matt associated with, but none of them could provide investigators with anything that could point to where Matt was. Searches of the area and the five acre property Matt's grandfather owned came up empty, as did a neighborhood canvas of home security systems that may have captured images of Matt during the time he vanished. Since Matt vanished, his bank account have not been touched, and his grandfather passed away leaving Matthew as his heir. The estate can not be settled until Matt can be located. In this episode, John Jobe who had dated Matt's mom for many years before her death, stayed close with Matt and considered him like a stepson. In this episode, John discusses the frustration of not being able to find out what happened to Matt as well as the lack of coverage in Matt's case. Matthew Yeomans is described as being 5'8 and weighing about 170 pounds with green eyes and brown hair.Anyone with information about Matthew's case is asked to call 508-230-3322.If you'd like to support this podcast via a donation, you can do so through Patreon here-https://www.patreon.com/MissingPodcastTo contact the podcast or learn more about the cases we discuss visit:Missingpersonspodcast.comFollow us on Social media-Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/Missing-Persons-Podcast-103501877912153orTwitter:https://twitter.com/Missing_Pod

Episode 66 Jesse Farber29 year old Jesse Lee Farber vanished from Tamaqua, PA on Aug. 11, 2015 and hasn't been seen since. The mystery of what happened to Jesse started with a strange phone call to his girlfriend in which Jesse claimed he was being chased by coyotes in the Sharp Mountain area. Jesse told his girlfriend that he had gone up a tree and needed help, and asked her to bring a gun. When help showed up in the area where Jesse was supposed to be, he was no where to be found. Extensive searches of the rugged area where Jesse vanished from came up empty. Then, in December, 2016, more than a year after Jesse vanished, a hunter found his sweatpants in a tree on a remote, steep mountainside near the top of Sharp Mountain. Jesse's backpack was higher up in the same tree. However, there was no sign of Jesse, and he has never been found. Jesse Farber is described as a White male, 5'5 - 5'7, 130 pounds Brown hair, brown eyes. He has a chipped front tooth and may use the name Jesse Rex. Jesse has a dog bite scar on each cheek and a small scar on his forehead. He has numerous tattoos, including a fox on his left upper arm at the shoulder, a black star wreath above the Roman numerals II, III and IV on the inside of his left forearm, a small ankh symbol on his left forearm, a skull with a snake coming out of it on his right upper arm at the shoulder, a colorful dragon's skull and words in black Gothic script on his upper back, a bear claw print on the right side of his chest, and a stick figure drawing in a keyhole shape on the left side of his ribcage showing a scene of a man hanging from a tree. If you have information about the disappearance of Jesse Farber, please call the Tamaqua Police Department 570-668-5000.To learn more about Jesse's case, visit:https://www.facebook.com/JesseFarberMissingorhttps://www.facebook.com/groups/556815316078112

Episode 65 Nicole Bell31 year old Canadian mother of 3 Nicole Bell, who was described as a soccer mom, vanished mysteriously on September 2, 2017. That day while her husband was at work and her kids were at school, Nicole updated her Facebook page in her Malakwa home. After that, she vanished. Her husband returned home to find the house empty. Her car which Nicole couldn't drive because it had been broke down was still in the driveway. Not long after she vanished, Nicole's cell phone was found in the area of Salmon Arm, about 50 kilometers or about 31 miles from her home. Nicole has not been seen since, and her family is worried about her as it was not like her to leave home. Also concerning, is that during a two year period in that area, several women either went missing or turned up dead. Nicole's mom, Jane Aubertin, is the guest in this episode and discusses her daughter's baffling disappearance, and her frustration at the lack of transparency on the part of police investigating the case.Nicole is described as Caucasian, 4’11” tall, and has blonde hair past her shoulders. She has a piercing in her nose and above her upper lip and occasionally wears glasses.Anyone with information about the whereabouts of Nicole Bell is asked to contact the Sicamous RCMP at 250-836-2878, or Crime Stoppers, if they wish to remain anonymous, at 1-800-222-8477, quoting file number 2017-1401Visit the Facebook group about Nicole set up by her mom:https://www.facebook.com/groups/253501049551467If you'd like to support this podcast via a donation, you can do so through Patreon here-https://www.patreon.com/MissingPodcastTo contact the podcast or learn more about the cases we discuss visit:Missingpersonspodcast.comFollow us on Social media-Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/Missing-Persons-Podcast-103501877912153orTwitter:https://twitter.com/Missing_Pod

Episode 64 Kara Hyde23 year old Kara Hyde was last seen in Hamilton, Ohio on December 5th, 2021. When she left her mom Lisa Smith's home, Lisa had no idea it would be the last time she'd see her daughter. Kara was struggling mentally, and with drug use, and was not in a good place in her life. She had disappeared for short stints before, so Lisa was not quick to report Kara missing. But this time, Kara never came home, and Lisa has struggled over the last year trying to find her daughter. She's resorted to checking on tips and leads herself. Some of Kara's belongings were found, but Kara herself was not. Lisa discusses her daughter's case in this episode.Missing from: Hamilton, OhioMissing since: 12/5/2021Missing age: 23Current age: 24Gender: FemaleRace/Ethnicity: WhiteHeight: 5'8"Weight: 120 lbsHair color: BlondeEye color: BrownIf you have information contact Hamilton Police Department at (513) 868-5811Check out Kara's Facebook group Find Kara Hyde:https://www.facebook.com/groups/272234971559207If you'd like to support this podcast via a donation, you can do so through Patreon here-https://www.patreon.com/MissingPodcastTo contact the podcast or learn more about the cases we discuss visit:Missingpersonspodcast.netFollow us on Social media-Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/Missing-Persons-Podcast-103501877912153orTwitter:https://twitter.com/Missing_Pod

Episode 63 Tracy Epps AKA Tracy Butler Tracy Epps, AKA Tracy Butler, had a lot going for her. The Virginia Grandmother had a career, an active social life, and was close with her family and friends. But when she began a relationship with and secretly married a man named LC Epps, those closest to Tracy began to see dramatic changes in her behavior. Tracy became withdrawn, and seemed to be under LC's control. She stopped working, and bounced aimlessly from hotel to hotel with her new husband. Tracy's family was very concerned for her health and safety, and they had good reason to be. A check of LC's background revealed a long and violent criminal record. When her family confronted Tracy over her new husband's past and tried to encourage her to leave him, Tracy defended him and said he had changed. In March, 2022, LC was killed in a confrontation with police while brandishing a gun. When police searched for Tracy to deliver the news, they discovered that the 56 year old woman was no place to be found, and that she hadn't been seen by friends and family in the days leading up to LC's fatal interaction with police. When Tracy's family discovered she was missing, they feared the worse. A check of Tracy and LC's hotel room, and surveillance video from the hotel revealed troubling evidence that led both police and Tracy's family to conclude that something violent occurred between LC and Tracy, and that as a result, Tracy was dead. The clues seem to point to LC hiding or disposing of Tracy's remains, but to date, they have not been found. Tracy's family is heartbrohen and desperate to bring Tracy home, and giver her a proper goodbye. In this episode, Tracy's niece Katherine discusses this tragic case, and their efforts to find out what happened. Anyone with information can call Henrico Police (804) 501-4878. Anonymous tips may be submitted by calling Crime Stoppers at (804) 780-1000 or online at p3Tips.com.If you'd like to support this podcast via a donation, you can do so through Patreon here-https://www.patreon.com/MissingPodcastTo contact the podcast or learn more about the cases we discuss visit:Missingpersonspodcast.netFollow us on Social media-Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/Missing-Persons-Podcast-103501877912153orTwitter:https://twitter.com/Missing_Pod

Episode 62 Michael Havekost52 Year old Michael Havekost was new to the Killeen, TX area when he vanished there in early September, 2021 during the covid pandemic. A transplant from Indiana, Michael was living temporarily at the Day Night Inn located at 6200 East Veterans Memorial Blvd. He had lost his job as a dishwasher, and his sister Sarah Holley who is the guest in this episode, lived nearby and was helping Michael as needed. When Michael went missing, Sarah became alarmed because it wasn't like him to leave home for any period of time. When Sarah learned that Michael had left behind his glasses, and hearing aids; both of which he relied on, she really became concerned. Michael's wallet was also left behind. Sarah is desperate to find her brother. Michael Havekost is described as being 5 feet, 8 inches tall, weighing 160 pounds, with bald or very short blond hair and hazel eyes. Anyone with information about Michael Havekost is asked to contact the Killeen Police Department at 254-501-8800.Residents can also contact the Bell County Crime Stoppers at 254-526-8477 Visit the Facebook group set up for Michael's case:https://www.facebook.com/groups/355581422400294If you'd like to support this podcast via a donation, you can do so through Patreon here-https://www.patreon.com/MissingPodcastTo contact the podcast or learn more about the cases we discuss visit:Missingpersonspodcast.netFollow us on Social media-Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/Missing-Persons-Podcast-103501877912153orTwitter:https://twitter.com/Missing_Pod