It’s inevitable that your favorite musician will one day call it quits. Yet that doesn’t mean you’re not dreading the moment when that artist announces their final tour or album. Just the thought of said artist never playing again makes you depressed… so which band or artist do you never want to see retire?

That’s what Matt Gamba and Zach Shaw determine in this episode of Epic Footnote Productions’ “If You Have to Pick 3 … ,” a podcast where we have to pick their top three choices on any given topic (bands, albums, songs, genres, whatever!). After they each share their personal favorites, they then have to come to an agreement on a final top 3.