On a weekday afternoon in 1985 in Gary, Indiana, fifteen-year-old Paula Cooper stabbed 78-year-old Ruth Pelke to death. In a city with a history of racism, Ruth was a white, beloved bible teacher who refused to move out of her overwhelmingly black neighborhood. When Paula and her friends showed up at Ruth’s door that day asking about bible studies, Ruth had happily invited them in.
Join us at the quiet end for Death Sentence: The Murder of Ruth Pelke & the Punishment of Paula Cooper. When Paula was sentenced to death, few argued against the state’s impending execution of a tenth grader. But when the victim’s grandson forgave the girl, the media brought the story to the forefront and millions signed petitions in support of Paula. This case raises questions about the value of a human life and whether our justice system is made for rehabilitation or retribution.
Subscribed with PayPal? Click here to update TCB Premium Payment info
Support the show for ad-free, early, bonus episodes and more!
Record a voicemail for a future show
Join our True Crime Brewery Fan Discussion Group
Sources
A Clear Scientific Consensus that the Death Penlty Does Not Deter, Amnesty International, retrieved 3/14/2024,
A Pause in Federal Executions, but Uncertainty About What’s Next, The New York Times, Hailey Fuchs, 7/22/2021
Biden vowed to end the death penalty. Activists are demanding action as he nears the 100-day mark, CNN.com, Christina Carrega, 4/25/2021
Do Executions Lower Homicide Rates: The Views of Leading Criminologists’ Michael L. Radelet Traci L. Lacock, Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, Winter 2009,
IndyStar Archives 1985-2017
Seventy Times Seven: A True Story of Murder and Mercy by Alex Mar, 2023
April Kauffman didn’t have an easy life growing up. When she was just seventeen, she gave birth to her daughter Kim and set out to make a better life for them both. April raised her daughter in a loving home despite an early split from Kim’s father. She earned her cosmetology license and worked as a hairdresser and as a model. April was fun, energetic, and independent. But life as a single mom could be lonely.
Join us at the quiet end for The Dr. & Mrs. Kauffman. In 2002, April believed she had finally found her happily ever after when she married Dr. Jim Kauffman, a successful physician and a former green beret. As the wife of a Vietnam Veteran, April became an outspoken radio personality and a fierce veteran’s advocate. But Dr. Kauffman had a dark side which April began to uncover. The doctor was running a pill mill out of his medical office and associating with a criminal motorcycle gang: The Pagans. When April had had enough and threatened divorce, she began to realize that her life was in danger, and she might never make it out of this marriage alive.
Subscribed with PayPal? Click here to update TCB Premium Payment info
Support the show for ad-free, early, bonus episodes and more!
Record a voicemail for a future show
Join our True Crime Brewery Fan Discussion Group
Sources
April Kauffman, https://everipedia.org/wiki/lang_en/april-christine-kauffman-atlantic-city-new-jersey, retrieved 2/27/2024
http://aprilkauffman.net/, retrieved. 2/27/2024
Doctor Dealer: A doctor high on greed, a biker gang high on opioids, and the woman who paid the ultimate price, George Anastasia and Ralph Cipriano, 2020
The Doctor, the Hitman & the Motorcycle Gang : the true story of one of New Jersey’s most notorious murder for hire plots, Annie McCormick, 2020
Doctor’s Orders, Discovery Plus, 9/3/2021
Husband of slain radio host paid man to kill his wife 5 years ago, authorities say, NJ.com, True Jersey, Chris Franklin, 09/3/2018
Punishing Pill Mill Doctors: Sentencing Disparities in the Opioid Epidemic, William & Mary Law School, Adam M. Gershowitz, 12/2020
Who Was April Kauffman: Her Life, Her Mysterious Death and Why None of it Makes Any Sense, Boardwalk Journal, Sarah Colson and Ian Licht, 6/2012
With our promo code BREWERY20, you get 56% off your subscription of Magic Mind in the next 10 days and 20% off your one-time purchase.
You can get it at www.magicmind.com/brewery and redeem the discount code BREWERY20!
The Halderson family appeared to be living a happy middle-class life. Parents Krista and Bart had everything they had wished for and worked for, including a comfortable suburban home and two loving sons. Mitchell, 24, was working in the tech industry and Chandler, 23, was a college student living at home. But all was not as it seemed with Chandler.
Join us at the quiet end for Parent Trap. Chandler Halderson was weaving a complex web of lies for years. His college degree and job prospects were not what he portrayed them to be. In fact, Chandler’s life was going nowhere and his father was becoming frustrated and suspicious. But before Krista and Bart could uncover their son’s lies, the couple disappeared. Over the days that followed, evidence revealed that Chandler Halderson would stop at nothing, including murder, to protect his life of deception.
Subscribed with PayPal? Click here to update TCB Premium Payment info
Support the show for ad-free, early, bonus episodes and more!
Record a voicemail for a future show
Join our True Crime Brewery Fan Discussion Group
Sources
Chandler Halderson Trial, Channel 3000, https://www.channel3000.com/news/chandler-halderson-trial/, retrieved 1/3/2024
Parricide: An Introduction for Clinical and Forensic Mental Health Professionals, researchgate.net, Kimberly D. Dodson, 9/2017
State of Winconsin v. Chandler M. Halderson, Circuit Court Dane County Wisconsin, 8/24/2021
Timeline: Order of Events leading up to Chandler Halderson’s trial, WKOW.com, Sierra Rehm, 1/3/2022
Unemployed Son Mooched Off Parents He Killed and Dismembered, Claimed to Be College Student Who Got Job at SpaceX: Prosecutor, Law & Crime, Alberto Luperon, 1/4/2022
Try Magic Mind with out promo code Brewery20
Karla Brown was 22-years-old in 1978. After five-years of an off and on relationship, she and her fiancé, Mark, bought their first home together. That June, the couple were focused on moving and decorating their new home. They had friends over to help with the move on June 20th, followed by an evening of food and drinks. Next door, at the home of Paul Main, the pretty and outgoing Karla had not gone unnoticed.
Join us at the quiet end for Finding Karla Brown’s Killer. Karla’s fiancé Mark went to work on June 21st, leaving Karla home alone. Between 10 and 11am, Karla ended a phone call with her future mother-in-law, telling her that someone was at the door. By the time Mark returned home that day, Karla would be the victim of a brutal murder and the focus of a lengthy, complex investigation.
Support the show for ad-free, early, bonus episodes and more!
Record a voicemail for a future show
Join our True Crime Brewery Fan Discussion Group
Sources
Bite Mark Identification- A Relieable Forensic Tool or Junk Science, Penn State Dickinson Law, Samuel D. Hodge Jr., Robert E. Rains, 7/1/2017
The Karla Brown story: What happened and the latest updates, Tuko.co.ke, Florence Wanjiru, 4/5/2022
PCAST, Court Decisions Assessing the Admissibility of Forensic Science Evidence,
Forensic Science in Criminal Courts: Ensuring Scientific Validity of Feature-Comparison Methods
PEOPLE v. PRANTE, Supreme Court of Illinois, The People of the State of Illinois, Appellant, v. John Prante, Appellee. Decided: 5/12/2023
Silent Witness: The Karla Brown Murder Case by Don W. Weber and Charles Bosworth, Jr.
Elana Steinberg’s husband, Steve Steinberg, was a well-liked restaurant manager with a gambling problem. Elana struggled to keep their finances afloat, but it wasn’t easy. Then, on an otherwise normal night in 1981, Elana was stabbed 26 times in their bed. Steve called 911 and told the dispatcher that two bearded men had robbed them and killed his wife.
Join us at the quiet end for Victim on Trial: Elana Steinberg. It wasn’t long after Elana’s murder when Steve confessed that he had killed her. Put on trial for murder, Steve’s defense was temporary insanity. Yes, he had killed his wife, but he had done it while sleepwalking. And, Elana had led him to it with her nagging and shopping. Prepare to be outraged. This is a case where the killer was treated as a long-suffering victim and the real victim was put on trial.
Support the show for ad-free, early, bonus episodes and more!
Record a voicemail for a future show
Join our True Crime Brewery Fan Discussion Group
Sources
Crime/mystery: The Defense Pleaded Nagging, The New York Times, Tony Hillerman, 10/9/1988
Death of a Jewish American Princess by Shirley Frondorf
Homicidal Sleepwalking: To Kill While Asleep, TimeTraveller.org, Fiona Guy, 10/26/2017
On March 18, 1990, 15-year-old fraternal twins Dannette and Jeanette Millbrook disappeared while out walking from a convenience store to their home in Augusta, Georgia. Earlier that day, the girls told their mother that a man in a white van had been following them. Nothing more is known about this man and he would not be the only person of interest in the girls’ disappearance.
Join us at the quiet end for The Missing Millbrook Twins. Dannette and Jeanette’s mother reported them missing that same evening, but she was told that she had to wait for 24 hours. Even after the 24 hours passed, the sheriff’s office failed to investigate or follow up in any way with the family. In fact, when the girls’ 17th birthday passed, the case was closed. The sheriff’s explanation? The girls were now old enough that they could not be forced to return home. This suggests that the girls were runaways, but there was no reason to believe this to be true. In fact, it seems clear that two poor black children were not a priority for the sheriff’s department and a significant injustice was done when they never bothered to look for Dannette and Jeanette. Is it too late now or is there a chance that this cold case can somehow be solved?
Support the show for ad-free, early, bonus episodes and more!
Record a voicemail for a future show
Join our True Crime Brewery Fan Discussion Group
If you have any information on the Millbrook twins, please contact the Richmond County PD non-emergency line at 706-821-1020
Sources
The Disappearance of the Millbrook Twins, Oxygen True Crime, 2019.
The Fall Line Podcast, Season 1, created by Laurah Norton & Brooke Hargrove, 6/12/2017-7/31/2017.
Frustrated Sister of Missing Twins Says Sheriff Hasn’t Fixed ‘Terrible Injustice,’ Huffington Post, David Lohr, 6/26/2017, ret. 12/28/2023.
How Black and Indigenous Women are Detrimentally affected by ‘Missing White Woman Syndrome,’ UAB Institute for Human Rights Blog, Mary Bailey, 11/1/2021, ret. 12/30/2023.
Little Sister Still Searching for Twins Dannette and Jeannette Millbrook Last Seen in Augusta, Georgia in 1990, NBC Cold Case Spotlight, Sarah Portney, 4/22/2023, ret. 12/28/2023.
Missing Dannette and Jeanette Millbrook, Facebook, https://www.facebook.com/twwinsfammily/
Runaway Youth: Caring for the Nation’s Largest Segment of Missing Children, American Academy of Pediatrics, Clinical Report, 2/1/2020.
At 6:00 a.m. on August 28, 1965, Carl and Carmela Coppolino’s physician, Dr. Juliette Karow, was awakened by a phone call. Carl Coppolino tearfully described to her how he had just found his 32-year-old wife dead, seemingly from a heart attack. Dr. Karow was concerned when she arrived at the house—young women in their 30s rarely die from cardiac arrest.
Join us at the quiet end for The Love Triangle Murders. Forty-one days after his wife’s death, Carl Coppolino married Mary Gibson. Imagine the chagrin of the Coppolino’s neighbor Marjorie Farber, who had moved from New Jersey to Florida in hopes of being with Carl. Incensed by this turn of events, Marjorie went to the police and told them that she had stood by helplessly as her husband was strangled to death by Carl. And she had information to share about Carmela’s death as well!
Support the show for ad-free, early, bonus episodes and more!
Record a voicemail for a future show
Join our True Crime Brewery Fan Discussion Group
Sources
The Crime That Never Was by Carl Coppolino, 1980.
No Deadly Drug by John MacDonald, 1968.
State v. Coppolino, Florida District Court, 1968-1970.
Tracing the Untraceable, Time.com, 5/5/1967, ret. 12/18/2023
The Trials of Dr. Coppolino by Paul Holmes, 1968.
coppolino-1-248x300.jpg" alt="" width="248" height="300">
On December 22, 1987, Ronald Gene Simmons began a killing spree that would become the worst massacre in Arkansas history as well as the deadliest domestic crime in the history of the United States. His murderous rampage ended six days later, leaving fourteen members of his family and two former coworkers dead.
Join us at the quiet end for The Christmas Vacation Massacre. Gene Simmons was a nightmare from early on in his marriage. He went from controlling but hard-working military man, to wife beater, to incestuous father, and, in the end, to a merciless mass murderer.
Sources
Arkansas Man Sentenced to Death for Killing 14 Members of his Family, Deseret News, 2/12/1989.
The Devil of Pope County: America’s Worst Family Massacre Podcast, Tony Holt, 2023
Ronald Gene Simmons, 1940-1990, Encyclopedia of Arkansas, retrieved 12/12/2023
Zero at the Bone: Story of Gene Simmons Mass Murder, Marshall & Williams, 1991.
1-1-300x300.jpg" alt="" width="300" height="300">
Just nine days before Christmas 1998, thirty-three-year-old Ronda Reynolds was getting ready to visit her mother for the holidays. Ronda’s second marriage was falling apart after less than a year and her career as a Washington State Trooper had ended badly, but her friends and family would insist that Ronda had still been optimistic about her future. Barb Thompson, Ronda’s mother, was just happy that Ronda was coming home. But then a call early in the morning changed Barb’s life forever.
Join us at the quiet end for Who Killed Ronda Reynolds? Ronda’s soon-to-be ex, Ron Reynolds, had called 911 that morning to say that Ronda had committed suicide in their bedroom closet. Over the next several years, the coroner would change Ronda’s manner of death from “undetermined” to “suicide,” not once, but twice. But Barb Thompson never believed that her daughter committed suicide. Finally, Ron was arrested for Ronda’s homicide. But would there be enough evidence to get a conviction?
Support the show for ad-free, early, bonus episodes and more!
Record a voicemail for a future show
Join our True Crime Brewery Fan Discussion Group
Sources
Former Trooper Ronda Reynold’s Death Ruled Homicide, Seattle Times, 10/19/2011
Husband in notorious Lewis County murder case to leave job as school principal, Seattle Times, Cathy McLain, 8/23/2012
Husband, Stepson arrested, freed in ex-trooper’s death, Seattle Times, Adam Pearson, 10/28/2011
In the Still of the Night by Ann Rule
Mystery on Twin Peaks Drive, 48 Hours, E25 S21, 4/21/2012, retrieved 12/4/2023
In June of 1959, just two months before her thirteenth birthday, Lynne Harper was found dead in a wooded grove near a Clinton, Ontario, Air Force base. Lynne was small for her age, the middle child between two brothers. She was described as bossy and a “live wire.” She had her whole life ahead of her.
Join us at the quiet end for Two Innocents. The last person seen with Lynne on the day she disappeared was 14-year-old classmate Steven Truscott. Despite a lack of any physical evidence and witness accounts which gave Steven a clear alibi, he was arrested for Lynne’s murder just days after her body was found. Then, Steven was found guilty and sentenced to hang. This is the story of Lynne’s murder, Steven’s unjust conviction, the people who worked to free him and exonerate him of his murder conviction, and the continuing mystery of who was really responsible for this terrible crime.
Support the show for ad-free, early, bonus episodes and more!
Record a voicemail for a future show
Join our True Crime Brewery Fan Discussion Group
Sources
Can Science Clear Truscott? thestar.com. 1/29/2007, retrieved 11/20/2023.
Steven Truscott Case, The Canadian Encyclopedia, https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/steven-truscott-case, retrieved 11/25/2023.
Steven Truscott: His Word Against History, The Fifth Estate, 2015, retrieved 11/25/2023.
Steven Truscott, Innocence Canada, Sarah Harland-Logan, 2023.
Until You Are Dead: Steven Truscott’s Long Ride into History by Julian Sher, 2001, 2023.
Victim’s Family stunned by Truscott Compensation, CBS News, 7/8/2008, retrieved 11/14/2023
Youngest Canadian Sentenced to Death is Cleared in 1959 Case, The Seattle Times, 8/29/2007, retrieved 11/14/2023.
Dick and Jill were a "normal" married couple, living a wholesome vegan life behind their white picket fence. Could it be that behind the façade, lies an obsession with violence, murder, and the dark side of human nature? They do their homework, all right, in the best tradition of amateur sleuthing. Fun to listen to, and enlightening, even for veteran True Crime buffs. "Pull up a chair at the quiet end" and listen while Jill and Dick unspool another grim story in their sweet, simple, and uncompromising style, and enjoy delightful reviews of craft brew beers as well.
I enjoy listening to TBC. So glad I found this true crime podcast!!!