It's time to solve one of history's mysteries! The boys roleplay as historians as they try to solve what happened to the lost colony of Roanoke!

Join Nick and Ryan as they debate this long-standing enigma. Is it as Nick says and that the colonists went to live with the nearby native Croatoans? Or is it an awkward surprise birthday party gone awry like Ryan posits? Either way, it'll be up to Ben to judge who is right.

Discussion points include: awkward surprise parties, Croatoan, looting, Sir Walter Raleigh, anagrams, blonde hair and blue eyes, the Zuniga map, historians, underground tunnels, and mashing up children's bones.