The guys welcome back Mariah to talk about another one of her Childhood Movies (TM, All Rights Reserved). This time, it's 2004's A Cinderella Story starring Hilary Duff and Chad Michael Murray. The gang all marvel at how quick Chad Michael Murray is at texting, they pull their hair out at the movie trying to convince everyon that Duff is a plain-Jane, Mariah points out all the horribly-aged dialogue/jokes, there is a VERY heated debate about the ending and much more. Plus: Rudy Giuliani does NOT care for this movie and he's writing a letter! Check our social media on Sunday for the Sunday Screencrap and take a guess at our next movie! What We've Been Watching: Fresh "The Thing About Pam" "Witnessing a Disaster" Questions? Comments? Suggestions? You can always shoot us an e-mail at wwttpodcast@gmail.com  What Were They Thinking is sponsored by Manscaped! Get 20% OFF manscaped + Free Shipping with promo code WWTT at MANSCAPED.com! Patreon: www.patreon.com/wwttpodcast Facebook: www.facebook.com/wwttpodcast Twitter: www.twitter.com/wwttpodcast Instagram: www.instagram.com/wwttpodcast Theme Song recorded by Taylor Sheasgreen: www.facebook.com/themotorleague Logo designed by Mariah Lirette: www.instagram.com/its.mariah.xo Montrose Monkington III: www.twitter.com/montrosethe3rd A Cinderella Story stars Hilary Duff, Chad Michael Murray, Jennifer Coolidge, Dan Byrd, Madeline Zima, Julie Gonzalo, Simon Helberg, Lin Shaye, Paul Rodriguez and Regina King; directed by Mark Rosman. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices